Subhadda -the last direct disciple

The historical Buddha, Shakyamuni Buddha enter parinirvana at  Kuśinagara. At that time, an ascetic by the name of Subhadda visited Buddha.

Buddha had already announced that He would enter Parinirvana that day and thus Ananda refused to let Subhadda meet Buddha. However, Buddha instructed Ananda not to obstruct Subhadda.

This meeting, resulted in Subhadda gaining enlightenment. Therefore, he became the last disciple to be personally enlightened and ordained by Shakyamuni Buddha.

Importantly, it also resulted in the Buddha’s answer to an important question.

Subhadda asked Buddha if enlightenment can be found outside the Teachings of Buddha. At that time, there were many religious teachers who claimed to be enlightened. Therefore, Subhadda wanted to know if those teachers and their teachings will lead to Enlightenment. Subhadda then listed some names of famous teachers and asked the Buddha for verification.

Buddha instructed Subhadda not to raise such question and instead taught that (1) Enlightenment can be attained as long as a teaching contains the Noble Eightfold path. (2) Buddha proclaimed that His teaching contains the Noble Eightfold path and (3) that there are no enlightened people outside of this path. (4) As long as the Noble eightfold path is being practiced, enlightenment of sentient beings will continue.

I think this demonstrated the wisdom of Buddha.

Foremost, it is futile to seek the opinion of others when we wish to learn more about a person. Just like Subhadda, trying to know whether other religious teachers were enlightened.

If we truly wish to find out more about another person, we have to associate with them to form our own conclusion. In this manner, I think the Buddha is super wise and cool. Subhadda was kinda like soliciting gossips from Buddha!

Instead, Buddha provided the answer to a question that is gnawing at Subhadda’s subconsciousness. It shows that Buddha knows! That is why Subhadda attained the first stage of enlightenment immediately when he heard Buddha’s answer.

Enlightenment is not dependent on an external power or personality. It is about how we adjust our mind to see the truth. It is all about applying the correct method to heal our own delusional mind.

Therefore, instead of being concerned and distracted about whether another master or person is enlightened, Buddha taught Subhaddha how enlightenment can be achieved by the Noble eightfold path. He showed Subhadda how enlightenment works!

As mentioned previously,Subhadda attained the stream-enterer stage of enlightenment after hearing Buddha’s answer. Subhadda became a monk immediately and started his meditation without wasting any time. He attained full enlightenment (4th stage of enlightenment) before Buddha enter parinirvana! All this happened within one night before the sun rose on the next day.

It is note worthy to know that Shakyamuni Buddha is a Samyaksam Buddha. This means that He rediscovered the Truth and taught the Truth at a time when nobody else knew about it.

That means he is the original author of the Noble Eightfold path. There can only be one Buddha.

Today, if a person who had never read Buddhism before were to write a book about Noble eightfold path from his own creativity and start his own religion. That person cannot be credited as an original author. Neither will he be credited as a Buddha. This is because he might have learnt it in his previous life time. That is also why knowledgeable Buddhist will never take another person seriously if that person proclaim himself a Buddha. (That proclamation itself is delusional…..)

Thus, we also conclude that

  1. Enlightenment can only be attained through the Buddha’s way. Only one way.
  2. The way is referred to as the Noble eightfold path. Regardless of cultural practice or outward appearance, we examine a teaching by looking for the Eightfold path approach. If it is there, then it will lead to enlightenment. That is why Buddhism can have many form and outward appearances. Your practice can look Japanese, Tibetan, Chinese,Thai, Sri Lankan, English etc. it doesn’t matter. What is important is to make sure the Noble Eightfold path is in your practice.

May all be well and happy.

Categories: Articles, Shakyamuni Buddha

Tagged as: ,

6 replies »

  1. Jamyang, this is just a splendid post about Buddha’s teachings, thank you. As you know by, I am a student of Buddhisms, practicing it every day as far as possible. At the moment I am reading a book by Karen Armstrong ” Buddha”, it’s more like a biography about Buddha’s life, a really interesting read, maybe you can it , what was striking to me as I am reading further on, that Buddha was a real human with all the struggles we all are having in our life time, I felt so relieved by reading this, that Buddha had the same thoughts and questions I have every day. Have a great weekend with “Minds together” from Cornelia

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you for sharing, Cornelia.

      It is heart warming to connect with Buddha in that way and see hope that all humans can become a Buddha.

      He started off as an ordinary person. Just like us.
      But he has extraordinary track records from his effort of perfecting himself in his many past lives. He retold his past lives stories to his disciples and this can be read in the Jataka tales.

      I think it is important that we remember that Buddha transcended the human weaknesses when he gained Enlightenment. The stage of Truth and deathlessness.

      It is important that we also remember enlightenment and nor loose sight of that goal.

      I have not read Karen Armstrong and I hope she is not an author that tries to humanize Buddha too much. Especially, about his life and thoughts after his enlightenment.

      This is because reader may then form a wrong conclusion about enlightenment by simply imagining it base on their human experience.

      I believe, that will be a road block to Buddha’s intention of teaching mind development that leads to enlightenment.

      Have fun with your reading and may wisdom arise. Have a great weekend too.


      • Thank you so much for your great response, Jamyang, I really appreciate that you took your time. Karen Armstrong doesn’t humanize Buddha at all, that’s what I like about her writing, because you say, readers or students would get an illusional image of The Buddha and absolutely it would block their growth towards enlightenment . It is so wonderful to communicate with a like minded person like you. Thank you Jamyal, and have a great week filled with inner growth. “Minds together” from Cornelia

        Liked by 1 person

      • Cornelia, thank you so much for sharing a good read with me. I never tired of reading lives of the Buddha. Hopefully I will find this book in the library and read it too. Once again, thanks for taking time to share.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.